ckquote>Belgium’s laws severely restrict freedom of speech and opinion. Now, one of the major protagonists of these laws has fallen victim to them. On November 14, Brussels court ruled that Emir Kir, a Brussels regional government member, denies the Armenian genocide and hence is committing a hate crime.
The court proceedings began after Kir, the Turkish-born Secretary of State of the Brussels Region and a leading Socialist politician in the Belgian capital, lodged a complaint against a website which criticized him for taking part in a demonstration of Turkish immigrants denying the Armenian Genocide. The court ruling against Kir confirms that the Armenian Genocide was a crime against humanity and that, consequently, it is not protected in Belgium under freedom of expression.
The verdict said that the website was “by no means wrong” in branding Kir as a genocide denier. It went on to note that this type of clear labelling serves the common good and advances the purposes established by Belgian law to penalize genocide denial. Secretary Kir said that he will appeal against the verdict.
The only genocide one is allowed to deny in Belgium is the one perpetrated by the Belgian King Leopold II in the Congo from 1885 to 1908. Though internationally historians hold that Leopold’s rule cost the lives of up to 10 million people, Belgian historians maintain that there is no agreement among historians that there ever was a genocide in the Congo.
But, as Belien informs us, Kir has appealed against the verdict:
Laurette Onkelinx, the Belgian minister of Justice and the PS deputy Prime Minister, told the Belgian Senate on 17 November that “additional legal and historic research” is needed to ascertain what really happened in Armenia in 1915. Clearly, courting the Muslim vote has led the Belgian government to doubt the Armenian genocide. How long will it take before Belgian parties start questioning the Shoah in order to attract Muslim votes?