Amir Taheri on why Afghanistan’s President Hamid Karzai is demanding that the US forge a long-term defense relationship with his newly liberated nation:
[W]hy a long-term military link with the United States? Because Afghanistan is located in a rough neighborhood where despotic regimes hold sway.
These regimes regard a democratic Afghanistan, as much as a democratic Iraq, as an existential threat. What would Iranians and their Arab neighbors think of their despotic regimes if the Afghans — who have always been dismissed as rustics, if not outright barbarians — are allowed to choose their own government and determine its policies through free elections?
Later this year, Afghanistan and Iraq will hold general elections in which dozens of political parties representing all the shades of the political spectrum will take part. In June’s Iranian presidential election, however, only candidates approved by the “Supreme Guide” will be allowed to stand, while all political parties remain banned.
Iran is not alone among Afghanistan’s neighbors to fear democratization in that country. Turkmenistan is suffocating under President Safar-Murad Niyazov’s medieval personality cult. Uzbekistan is a classic dictatorship built around President Islam Karimov. China is one of the world’s last remaining Communist regimes. Tajikistan, where an alliance of neo-Communists and Islamists holds power, may be less repressive but is no more democratic. And Pakistan, where political parties are theoretically allowed while their leaders are exiled, is yet to emerge from its tradition of see-sawing between democracy and military rule.