Progressive Realism

Written by

in

>

This lengthy first post is in the personal style, telling us of his close bond with the US secretary of state, Antony Blinken: “Tony and I are good friends, who share a love of music and have a similar outlook on the world of today.” Nice to know. But when it gets into complex policy matters, something bizarre appears. Lammy rightly denounces Putin’s false claim to be “seeking to ‘liberate’ Ukrainian civilians” but then veers wildly into the Caucasus: “The states of central Asia look increasingly east and south. Azerbaijan has been able to liberate territory it lost in the early 1990s … Only a few fragile regimes like Belarus, DPRK [North Korea] and Iran still align with Moscow.”

To be clear, what the foreign secretary extols here is the completion of the capture of the area of Nagorno-Karabakh from Armenia by Azerbaijan. As Professor Mark Movsesian of St John’s University law school observed: “The foreign secretary’s reference to the ‘liberation’ of Nagorno-Karabakh is shockingly callous and ignorant. In fact, exactly a year ago Baku ethnically cleansed the region of 120,000 Christian Armenian inhabitants in violation of an order from the International Court of Justice.”

And, as I wrote only last week, Azerbaijan is getting closer to Moscow, not further away: “President Aliyev and President Putin enjoy the best of relations. The Azeri leader welcomed the Russian to Baku in August, returning the hospitality he had received at the Kremlin four months earlier.” I also quoted Aliyev’s sinister remarks in a speech in 2022, which referred to ethnic Armenians as “barbarians and vandals” who “established a state for themselves in someone else’s land … Present-day Armenia is our land.”

As one long-standing member of the Labour Party with appreciation of this dispute furiously WhatsApped me, referring to Lammy’s extraordinary blog: “The muppet’s chosen to back a kleptocratic dictatorship over a post-Soviet nascent democracy.”

Lammy’s blundering intervention has not gone unnoticed in the US, where there is a large Armenian diaspora. The Democrat congressman Brad Sherman declared that “David Lammy’s comments on the Armenia crisis are a stain on UK foreign policy. He has endorsed ethnic cleansing.”

Add this to the partial ban on UK arms sales to Israel – our supposed ally now engaged in an existential war against Islamist forces bent on its complete elimination – and the signs are, to put it mildly, not good.

Comments

  1. Joanne Avatar

    Not too long ago, I read a chilling comment reflecting the Islamist perspective on Armenia: that it would be the next Israel.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *