Two Countries Divided

Written by

in

from across the Atlantic? Is it an anti-British thing? Or is there a raw nerve? – you know….hostages….Iran….that type of thing. Remember Operation Eagle Claw, to rescue the US hostages in Tehran in 1980?

An unforeseen low-level sandstorm caused two of eight helicopters to lose their way en route to Desert One, but only after men and equipment had been assembled there. A third helicopter suffered a mechanical failure and was incapable of continuing with the mission. Without enough helicopters to transport men and equipment to Desert Two, the mission was aborted. After the decision to abort the mission was made, one of the helicopters lost control while taking off and crashed into a C-130. In the ensuing explosion and fire, eight US servicemen were killed: five USAF aircrew in the C-130, and three USMC aircrew in the RH-53. During the evacuation, six RH-53 helicopters were left behind intact (5 of their serial numbers are 158686, 158744, 158750, 158753, and 158758). These six helicopters now serve with the Iranian Navy. In their haste to quickly evacuate the RH-53s, the aircrews inadvertently left behind classified plans that identified CIA agents within Iran.

And if you want real toe-curling abasement before Iranian power, it’s difficult to beat those American Christian leaders in their recent audience with Ahmadinejad.

Am I being petty here, scoring cheap points? Well yes, I am, but I find this all strangely annoying. It brings out the nationalist in me. Maybe it’s a minority view in the US – I certainly hope it’s a minority view – but really, if this is how Americans react to the difficulties of their closest ally, then – how would Oscar Wilde have put it? – fuck ’em.

It’d be sad if this Iranian stunt had the unforeseen consequence of driving a wedge between Britain and the US.

Comments

  1. expatmike Avatar
    expatmike

    ising of their government. etc.? Why didn’t Why didn’t the captured servicemen (and woman) just give name, rank and serial number and then keep quiet? That would have been dignified, I would have have thought. Don’t forget, the Iranians tried to capture an American patrol a month or so ago. The isolated American soldiers fought back and were eventually able to withdraw in good order.

  2. Anthony Avatar

    Mike,
    You have been taken in by Iranian propaganda hook, line, and sinker. Go and read what the sailors said yesterday about their experience yesterday, rather than taking the Iranian edited video footage at face value.

  3. John Barr Avatar
    John Barr

    “We got them released, unharmed, without any concessions”
    If you believe this, you missed the whole point of Krauthammer’s column. The fact that they got their agent back in exchange for the sailors will certainly encourage Iran to try this little maneuver again in the future. Not a good outcome.

  4. DaninVan Avatar
    DaninVan

    I’m sort of on the fence here. My only observation might be that if the Marines gave as up as much propaganda material as they did, with only minimal coercion, what would they have given up under exreme duress? Convoy schedules? Names of Iraqi sources?
    Every serving serviceman/woman should undergo the ‘captive experience’ before being sent into theatre.

  5. Noga Avatar

    I’m glad they are all back, alive and well. But I think there is a lesson to be learned here. If these same marines were patroling the English channel against some enemy, entrusted with the security of their own people, would they have made the same quick decision to surrender which they did in this case? What it makes clear is that people are not willing to risk their life for someone who is not their kin. In this case, the Iraqis.
    Which makes me wonder about the whole concept of “Humanitarian intervention” which the Euston Manifesto supports. How really feasible is it? How can the UN impose or expect the kind of soldierly “loyalty unto death” on its humanitarian missions which is probably essential to their success?

  6. Dom Avatar
    Dom

    Well, I’m confused too. This was hardly an Iranian victory, and I’m surprised that so many over here want to make it look that way. The whole Easter gift thing was silly. I really wish this would play itself out by everyone, both in Europe and America, praising the way Blair walked a tight-rope.
    Although I think it was petty of you to quote that bit about Eagle claw. That was Carter. We’ve blocked him out of the national conscious.

  7. mike Avatar
    mike

    Anthony: I wasn’t taken in. I always assumed some kind of pressure or manipulation. What I would have hoped for is a bit more resistance. Now the captives are selling their stories to the tabloids. Dignified? Not really.

  8. DaninVan Avatar
    DaninVan

    “…First Sea Lord Jonathon Band, the head of the Royal Navy, confirmed boarding operations involving British forces had been suspended.
    “For the moment we have stopped UK boarding operations,” Band told BBC radio. “We will obviously do a complete review.”
    http://www.netscape.com/viewstory/2007/04/07/-iran-urges-uk-goodwill-on-sailors/?url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.cnn.com%2F2007%2FWORLD%2Fmeast%2F04%2F07%2Firan.sailors%2Findex.html&frame=true
    A dime short and a fortnight late, Sir.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *