Pre-Existing Concepts

Written by

in

r brains.”

Scientists are stunned that a monkey can visually recognise its own species? And what’s this got to do with “pre-existing concepts in their brains”? If a monkey picks out red cards from a bunch of colours, does this mean it has a pre-existing concept of red in its brain? And out foraging for food – if it grabs a banana, does it mean it has a pre-existing concept of a banana?

Sadly I’ve been unable to find further details of this amazing breakthrough, but I did find this, from three years ago, showing that the contribution of these busy little Paignton macaques to the advancement of knowledge is nothing new:

Lecturers and students from the University of Plymouth wanted to test the theory that an infinite number of monkeys given typewriters would create the works of Shakespeare.

A single computer was placed in a monkey enclosure at Paignton Zoo to monitor the literary output of six primates.

But after a month, the Sulawesi crested macaques had only succeeded in partially destroying the machine, using it as a lavatory, and mostly typing the letter “s”. […]

Paignton Zoo scientific officer Dr Amy Plowman said: “The work was interesting but had little scientific value, except to show that the ‘infinite monkey’ theory is flawed.”

Hmm. Sounds like this Dr Amy Plowman is a few pre-existing concepts short of having a clue.

Comments

  1. SnoopyTheGoon Avatar

    But “s” is the highest frequency letter in the normal text, I believe, so it wasn’t all in vain. Apparently the monkeys are wise to this fact. Deep waters, I say…
    Re the ability of the monkeys to recognize their own species, it seems to me that the amazing part is that they manage to recognize a three-dimensional object in a two-dimensional image. This takes some training in humans as well.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *