Louis on Bob

Written by

in

A fine article by Louis Menand in the New Yorker, about Dylan.

On the East Coast folk scene that Dylan joined, and then, famously, left behind:

Nothing that Dylan did to get from Hibbing to “Blonde on Blonde” was scandalous, or even eccentric. He happened to come of musical age at a moment when rock and roll was moribund—Frankie Avalon stuff, songs for high-school sock hops. If you were serious, you played folk songs. And to become a folkie, unless you actually were from Oklahoma, you invented a persona. The whole folk revival was make-believe, anyway: it was urban kids trying to sound like hillbillies and sharecroppers. One of the folk-music veterans when Dylan came on the scene was Ramblin’ Jack Elliott, a singer with a cowboy twang who had once hoboed around with Guthrie himself. Ramblin’ Jack was the stage name of one Elliot Adnopoz, a Jewish kid from Flatbush whose father was a prominent surgeon. Cambridge was another center of the folk revival—it’s where Baez got her start, in the coffeehouses around Harvard Square. (She was a B.U. dropout.) There was a bluegrass group in that scene, composed mostly of college students, who called themselves the Charles River Valley Boys. Artifice was the price of authenticity.

And this quote from a Dylan interview – the one where he talked about his “wild mercury sound” on “Blonde on Blonde” – which I’d not come across before, about the sound of the streets:

That ethereal twilight light, you know. It’s the sound of the street with the sunrays, the sun shining down at a particular time, on a particular type of building. A particular type of people walking on a particular type of street. It’s an outdoor sound that drifts even into open windows that you can hear. The sound of bells and distant railroad trains and arguments in apartment buildings and the clinking of silverware and knives and forks and beating with leather straps. It’s all—it’s all there. Just lack of a jackhammer, you know.

It’s that “just lack of a jackhammer, you know” – only Dylan….

And on Dylan’s “gorgeous late-period croak”:

It sounds a little the way “Buena Vista Social Club” might have sounded if Cuba had been the birthplace of the blues.

Comments

  1. Dom Avatar
    Dom

    I guess I’m all alone here, but I never understood all the fuss surrounding Dylan. As a singer, barking dogs sound better. As a songwriter, he’s forgettable. The test of a good song is in the bridge, and Dylan hardly ever writes bridges. Billy Joel is far better.
    Is it his lyrics? If so, I still don’t get it. Sometimes the lyrics are just random words thrown on a page. Like this, which I think is a love song:
    “King Kong, little elves
    On the rooftops they dance
    Valentino-type tangos”
    Also, the lyrics seldom fit the music. Like “Farewell Angelina” again, melodically you expect a new thought, but he is still in the middle of a sentence. Billy Joel never does that.
    Just my $.02.

  2. Dom Avatar
    Dom

    Another $.02 — Why can’t Dylan hire a real harmonica player? He has a backup band anyway. When he ties that harmonica around his neck he looks like the chimney sweep in Mary Poppins, and doesn’t sound half as good. He can’t even “cup” it to get a good sound, he just sort of blows in and out.

  3. Mick H Avatar
    Mick H

    Billy Joel better than Dylan? I think I may have to ban you from this blog. Anyway, Farewell Angelina was an outtake from Another Side of…, and is associated with Joan Baez. I don’t think anyone would claim it was up there with Dylan’s best.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *