Fictitious Illness

Written by

in

e the MSBP sufferer can label as likely to have made the suggestion. Munchausen sufferers, as with most attention seekers, are always plausible and convincing.

It’s been estimated that as many as one in five cot deaths is really a murder resulting from a mother with Munchausen Syndrome By Proxy. The MSBP mother (who becomes a serial killer) knows that fear [by the police or investigating authorities] of accusing the wrong person is usually enough to evade accountability and prosecution. No-one is going to challenge a grieving mother, and the father may be in ignorance of what has really happened and thus steadfastly supporting his partner. Evidence is minimal and the cause of death is put down as cot death (also known as Sudden Infant Death Syndrome or SIDS), choking, breathing difficulties or some other plausible reason. However, MSBP is an ongoing condition and it is the repeated deaths from ambiguous or unidentified causes which arouse suspicion. There’s a saying in social services: one [death] is cot death, two is suspicious, three is Munchausen. But who is going to take the risk of wrongly accusing a bereaved mother or a caring nurse?

Including the wholly discredited notion of “one [death] is cot death, two is suspicious, three is Munchausen”, this just drips contempt for the silly immature mothers who clutter up hospitals and clinics with concern about their children’s health. It doesn’t take much to imagine how this goes down with social workers on the lookout for unsuitable parents.

It’s not the misdiagnosis of MSpB that’s the problem: it’s the definition of the illness itself.

Comments

  1. dearieme Avatar
    dearieme

    How is it that Social Workers always turn out to have been too busy to visit some house in which some defenceless mite is being tortured to death, but have time for dealing with fantastical cases?

  2. k Avatar
    k

    Interesting that one of the cases mentioned was Chronic Fatigue Syndrome, as some years ago in the late 90s, BBC Panorama did a show about lots of parents with CFS children being accused of MSbP, and the kids being taken and put in psychiatric wards. Yet recently in the news has been research showing that CFS people’s white blood cells are abnormal, and don’t fight infection properly.
    As regards adult CFS sufferers, a psychiatrist called Michael Sharpe is quoted as saying “the vehemence with which many patients insist that their illness is medical rather than psychiatric has become one of the hallmarks of the condition”.
    To me, that sounds very like the strength of the mother’s denial of abuse only serving to prove her guilty of MSbP.

  3. DaninVan Avatar

    Sounds like some Social Workers are practicing medicine without a license. Why exactly are the courts allowing Social Workers to present evidence which is clearly out of their area of expertise and experience?
    So much for innocent until proven guilty…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *