An Exchange of Ideas

Written by

in

photographer. The activity is not prohibited, but taking pictures in public, particularly of women, is taboo. Yet the British Council chose photography for its first art exhibition in Saudi Arabia, and in the most religiously conservative city, Riyadh. The show by British photographers is called Common Ground, but the candid picture it gives of Muslim life in contemporary Britain has little in common with this strict society.

The westernised dress and open lifestyle in Jagtar Semplay’s shots of Asian youth culture in Britain show a Muslim community in a state of flux between tradition and modernity. Suki Dhanda captures the relative freedom enjoyed by Shopna as she and her young friends play pool, or eat chips in a café. In pictures by Rehan Jamil, the only Muslim photographer, primary school children at the East London Mosque are taught unsegregated; elsewhere, a project worker scours a car park for Muslim heroin addicts.

It took six months of negotiation with ministries to convince them that there was no hidden agenda beyond a desire for cross-cultural bridge-building. In the event, the religious authorities censored two images containing crosses….

At the women-only private view last month, Baroness Uddin, the first Muslim woman to enter the House of Lords, urged other women to keep pushing the boundaries. The men’s private view the following evening was opened by Prince Saud al-Faisal, the Saudi Foreign Minister, and Jack Straw, the former Foreign Secretary, in Riyadh for bilateral talks. While Iyad Madani, the Minister of Culture and Information, spoke of the exhibition as providing “an opportunity for the exchange of ideas and experiences among photographers in the two countries”, and the prince sought “human understanding” between the two kingdoms, Straw spoke to the Muslim community in Britain. We are two religions but with one common ground, one civilisation, he said.

Two religions – but they won’t even allow images containing crosses. A fine example of human understanding, Saudi style.

Comments

  1. P. Froward Avatar

    Okay, they’re telling people in Saudi that Muslims in direct, sustained contact with the west turn into filthy damn westerners.
    That’ll build bridges. Totally
    But of course it’s true, so I guess there it is. And to be fair, they’re not showing anything half as bad as what folks in that part of the world are hearing in mosques. Was it here I saw a post about a taxi driver in Iran who’d mistaken western pornography for objective reportage? But maybe he’d just seen a documentary about Parliament.

  2. KevinG Avatar
    KevinG

    Have we both read the same report? This strikes me as being a wholly good thing. Rather than:
    ‘telling people in Saudi that Muslims in direct, sustained contact with the west turn into filthy damn westerners’
    it shows, to at least some, that muslims can, and do, live in and adapt to western cultures. For some it may be an eye-opener. I see nothing to be lost by this venture.

  3. P. Froward Avatar

    Kevin, you’re absolutely right: “It shows … that muslims can, and do, live in and adapt to western cultures”. That’s my point exactly. To somebody who sees adaptation as corruption, it’s not comforting. To somebody who regards gender segregation as a religious necessity commanded by God, boys and girls in the same class aren’t comforting.
    But as I said, these photos may suggest that westernization, while distinctly bad, really isn’t as spectacularly awful as the local imam claims. That would be a good thing.
    Then again, are we sure most of the customers at the “glossy marble King Fahd Cultural Centre” aren’t rich people who went to boarding schools in the UK? Who’s actually seeing these pictures?

  4. KevinG Avatar
    KevinG

    PF
    I do take your point(s). I have no idea who constitutes the audience for these pictures, but they’ve been approved by the authorites, and wayward questioning types may seek them out. They are there for those who might take something positive from them. I still think it’s a good thing and should be encouraged.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *