Learning from the West

Written by

in

ggest that the weapons inspectors in Iraq should have been given more time before the rush to war! He says:

‘…American thinkers and intellectuals warned Bush before the war that everything he needed to guarantee America’s security by removing weapons of mass destruction – assuming they existed – was at his disposal, that all countries were with him when it came to inspections, and that America’s interest did not require him to launch into a groundless war with unknown repercussions. But the black gold blinded him and he put his own private interests ahead of the American public interest….’

The above statement is like a microcosm of the trendy liberal argument against the war in Iraq: we should have let the weapons inspectors continue their job (bin Laden for Blix!) but because Bush is so addicted to oil (the ‘black gold’) he went ahead with the war anyway. Bin Laden even worries about the war having ‘unknown repercussions’, an echo of debates in the West about the unpredictability of war in Iraq and the concern that it might make all of us less rather than more safe. No wonder bin Laden namechecks ‘American thinkers and intellectuals’ – he got his political position on Iraq directly from them.

By the time of Iraq, bin Laden – who started out as a Saudi obsessive who wanted to make Saudi society even more chokingly religious – has become a fully-fledged Bush-basher, virtually indistinguishable from a new generation of journos and bloggers who see Bush as the most evil president ever and Iraq as the wickedest war of all time (they have short historical memories).

Comments

  1. Eric Avatar

    I can’t remember where I read/heard it, bu it was suggested that these translations were more accurate than some of the contemporary translations – and this in fact made Bin Laden look even more dangerous and hardline in certain parts.
    Surely, if this book makes some people understand how he can never be appeased, then its publication is a good thing?

  2. Mick H Avatar
    Mick H

    I’ve got no problem with the book being published. It strikes me as quite amusing though: it’s a commonplace on the Left that Osama’s a creation of the Right, as in, bogey man, the Other etc., but it turns out he’s more a creation of the Left. Plenty here for our cultural commentators to get their teeth into.

  3. Dom Avatar
    Dom

    The give-away is in bin-Laden’s eloquent use of the phrase “black gold”
    And then one day, he was shootin’ at some food
    And up through the ground come a bubblin’ crude
    Oil, that is … black gold … Texas tea
    Curse those Beverly Hillbillies !!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *