Dying Languages

ker of a major language: the bigger the better, and English best of all. Not because English is intrinsically superior, but because so many people and so many cultures speak it. If you’re one of the last speakers of Hixkaryana (a Brazilian language that reverses sentence order to put the object first and the subject last, apparently) then the conversations would tend, I would imagine, to be fairly limited. “Caught any fish today?” Or rather “Fish today, any caught?” (Or, “White men with tape recorder today, any seen?”, except they won’t have a word for “tape recorder”.) Basically it’s moribund. English, on the contrary, is thriving, constantly growing and changing, and the wonderful thing is, it’s all available to us. We understand and appreciate US writers, Australian writers, Anglophone Indian writers, and it’s pure gain: we don’t at the same time lose our appreciation of English culture. On the contrary we’re now better able to judge and appreciate it.

So yes, I’m all for the preservation of dying languages in theory: how can you possibly disapprove? But I’m very glad it’s not me who’s one of the few remaining speakers.

Comments

  1. Tim Dymond Avatar
    Tim Dymond

    I’d be careful using Keith Windschuttle as your source. He is the author of a denialist study of Settler-Aboriginal relations – attempting to claim that there was no frontier war between Aboriginals and white settlers. According to Windschuttle conialism has nothing to do with the wiping out of entire Aboriginal tribes, it was all the Aborigine’s own fault as they would not accept the peaceful ways aof Christian British settlers. Windschuttle historical claims have been discredited, and he has zero credibility on contemporary Aboriginal issues.

  2. Patrick Avatar

    Keith Windschuttle has zero credibility with some people, quite a lot with others.
    But that doesn’t prevent him from being a very controversial figure, and hence quoting him will always get some people offside, even if what he said (in whatever you happen to quote) is quite straightforward.
    It’s like illustrating an environmental point with a quote from Lomberg OR Greenpeace.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *