Things That Don’t Make Sense

Written by

in

n Fabrizio Benedetti of the University of Turin in Italy carried out the above experiment, he added a final twist by adding naloxone, a drug that blocks the effects of morphine, to the saline. The shocking result? The pain-relieving power of saline solution disappeared.

In the recent Edge Annual Question (what do you believe is true even though you cannot prove it?), John Skoyles had an interesting idea about the placebo effect: that we’d evolved such that our immune system was receptive to social factors, so if someone we believed had more expertise than us – a healer – gave us a “cure”, we reacted appropriately, ie our immune system gave up fighting and assumed the problem was over. Not sure how Benedetti’s finding would fit in with that, mind you.

Comments

  1. Backword Dave Avatar

    Hmmm. “our immune system gave up fighting and assumed the problem was over” seems a very odd definition of the placebo effect to me, and one I’m sure is wrong. I’d have to do some reading to be sure, but my off-the-top-of-my-head reaction is that placebos should spread infectious disease, which, AFAIK, they don’t.
    My present take on Benedetti is that some morphine-like chemical in the brain is involved in the placebo effect, and what happens is that, rather than the immune system stops fighting, the alarm system – the sensation of pain: “take your hand off the stove!” – is turned off.

  2. Mick H Avatar
    Mick H

    blem. I think your idea of a morphine-like chemical being involved is more plausible. But hell, what do I know.

  3. Backword Dave Avatar

    As for the cold fusion, and “The experimental case is bulletproof,” again, AFAIK, it’s not. When the scandal broke, Isaac Asimov wrote an essay on the weakness of the case, and suggested a few experiments which ought to show something. The only one I remember involved a double-blind (ie using experimenters who didn’t know which experimental group they were in) on the process with one group using heavy water and the other stuff from a tap. Given that heavy hydrogen is extremely rare, any result from the second group would make the fusion explanation highly unlikely.
    I’m prepared to accept that something happens in the experimental setup. I’m also prepared to be large sums of money that it is not fusion.

  4. Mick H Avatar
    Mick H

    I don’t know…there’s just no pleasing some people.

  5. Anthony Avatar

    Arrghhhh! Homeopathy rears its head!

  6. Mick H Avatar
    Mick H

    Yes, that’s a weird one. I’m beginning to wish I’d never posted this.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *