Understanding Religion

Written by

in

One of the more interesting recent books on psychology was Paul Bloom’s “Descartes Baby“. The title comes from Bloom’s belief – backed by an impressive range of experiments on infants – that we’re pretty much hard-wired to react differently to animate and inanimate objects. We expect objects we see as inanimate to behave in certain ways, but have entirely different expectations for objects we believe to have intentions and purpose. So, in effect, body-soul dualism is a function of the way our minds work – and modern philosophy of mind consists of increasingly convoluted attempts to get our minds – sorry, our brains – to think differently.

In this long article (via) Bloom sums up his position on the question of religious belief. It’s not exactly a revolutionary theory, but Bloom writes well, and makes a powerful argument:

Despite the vast number of religions, nearly everyone in the world believes in the same things: the existence of a soul, an afterlife, miracles, and the divine creation of the universe. Recently psychologists doing research on the minds of infants have discovered two related facts that may account for this phenomenon. One: human beings come into the world with a predisposition to believe in supernatural phenomena. And two: this predisposition is an incidental by-product of cognitive functioning gone awry.

Comments

  1. Juan Golblado Avatar
    Juan Golblado

    I think the predisposition is to assume that events have causes. 99% of the time it works well to expect to find a cause because you then attribute causality experimentally and see if it makes sense. If not you try something else. Trial and error is the scientific method, and it’s not even a social construct it’s a hard-wired phenomenon that most animals have. Eventually it works and the process stops.
    But when you try this causality-expectation instinct of ours against something like the weather, it throws you. you could go forever seeking specific causes for specific weather events. Or you could say, ‘God’ did it. And the process stops.

  2. P. Froward Avatar

    Offtopic, but I hope to be forgiven. Galloway has a new opening act on the Damascus circuit:
    http://www.arabicnews.com/ansub/Daily/Day/051122/2005112209.html

  3. P. Froward Avatar

    D’oh. I should’ve looked there first.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *